For decades, the American dream has involved owning a home, or maybe even two homes. It has been something to strive for, and a marker of success. However, as of late 2023, only about 66% of Americans own a house. That implies this dream is not for everyone, or is not necessarily attainable for everyone.

Is owning a home a good investment? Is this a dream we all should pursue? The answer is complicated.

First, let’s discuss some of the reasons purchasing a home may not be a good investment; then we’ll examine some reasons that it could be a good investment. Keep in mind, everyone’s circumstances are different, and these comments are generalizations that may or may not apply to your situation.

Reasons Buying a Home is Not a Good Investment

There Are Too Many Variables

Over the years, the housing market has gone through many cycles of boom and bust. Interest rates have dipped and then increased. Consumer demands have changed. Because of all these variables, it can be difficult to predict how much your home will be worth in five, ten, or twenty years. Keep in mind, the value of your home is only theoretical until you actually sell it. And when you’re ready to sell, what will the market look like?

Additionally, the neighborhood you’re living in could undergo changes that are beyond your control. A noisy road could be built nearby, a nearby river might flood, or an increase in crime might devalue the neighborhood. You can’t predict these events when you first move in.

Expenses Could Be High

Ramit Sethi, author of I Will Teach You To Be Rich, has said, “Rent is the maximum you will pay, but a mortgage is the minimum you will pay.” It’s true. As any homeowner can tell you, it can be expensive to upkeep a house and the surrounding property. Whether you’re replacing your furnace, paying for landscaping services, remodeling your kitchen, or dealing with unexpected plumbing repairs, the costs can add up quickly.

Renting might seem like throwing money away, but it also means not having to worry about many of these costs. Being a homeowner comes with a lot of financial responsibility that not everyone is prepared for. Keep in mind that you also have property taxes, homeowner’s insurance, and potentially homeowner’s association fees to budget for on top of your mortgage.

The ROI Does Not Necessarily Beat the Stock Market

As a financial advisor, it is difficult for me to recommend purchasing a home over investing in the stock market. Historically, the return on investment (ROI) from owning a home may not outperform investing in stocks over the long term. Stock investments offer liquidity, diversification, and the potential for higher returns compared to real estate. While a home can appreciate in value, it also requires ongoing maintenance costs that may eat into potential profits.

Additionally, building equity takes time. Typically, if you take out a 30-year mortgage, you will mostly pay off the interest first before paying down the principle. Since it may take years before you see significant returns, it might make sense to invest in the stock market instead, which offers more accessible growth potential and flexibility.

Reasons Buying a Home IS a Good Investment

Although I do not necessarily consider purchasing a home a surefire way of investing money, it does come with significant advantages, not all of which are monetary.

Gaining Peace of Mind

One of the main advantages of homeowner is the peace of mind that comes with having a place to call your own. Owning a home provides stability and a sense of security. You have control over your living space and can make it truly yours—hanging pictures, planting flowers, painting your walls whatever color you’d like, rearranging and remodeling when you please. This feeling of ownership and ability to customize your living environment can offer a level of comfort and security that renting may not provide.

Building Equity

Building equity is a key benefit of owning a home. As you pay off your mortgage, you are increasing the portion of the property that you truly own. This equity can be a valuable asset for future financial endeavors, such as taking out a home equity loan or line of credit. Additionally, as your home potentially appreciates in value over time, you may be able to sell it at a profit or leverage the equity to purchase another property or fund other investments.

Achieving Long-Term Stability

In addition to the emotional value, owning a home can also provide a sense of long-term financial security and stability. With fixed-rate mortgages, you have the advantage of predictable monthly payments, which can help with long-term financial planning. This stability can be especially beneficial during times of economic uncertainty or fluctuating rental markets. Owning a home gives you a sense of control over your living situation and can serve as a valuable asset for your future financial well-being. It can also be possible to borrow against your home, although I recommend exercising an abundance of caution when considering this.

As a homeowner, you are making a significant financial commitment with potential risks and rewards. It’s important to evaluate your long-term financial goals, risk tolerance, and personal circumstances before deciding whether to buy a home. While owning a home has emotional benefits and can provide a sense of stability, it’s essential to weigh these factors against the financial implications. Consulting with a financial advisor can help you make an informed decision based on your unique situation.

Leave a Reply